ECJ’s senior adviser backs Google in 'right to be forgotten' case

On Tuesday, in a formal opinion to the European Court of Justice (ECJ), Advocate General Niilo Jääskinen said that Internet search giant Google cannot be forced to pull down "damaging" content - which was legally posted elsewhere - from its search engine.

Noting that Google could not be held responsible for third party information in its search results, Jääskinen - the senior adviser to Europe's top court - said that the existing European Union (EU) data and privacy laws do not have any general "right to be forgotten."

Jääskinen's opinion comes in connection with a Spanish case which was referred to the ECJ. The case involves a Spanish man whose social security debts had led to the auctioning off of his property in 1998. However, the man found the information online when he searched for his own name ten years after the proceedings had been concluded and resolved.

A complaint was then filed by the man with Spain's data protection authority - Agencia Espanola de Proteccion de Datos (AEPD) - which sided with him in its ruling, However, Google appealed the AEPD verdict in one of Spain's highest courts; before the case was finally referred to the ECJ.

According to Jääskinen's opinion to the ECJ, Google cannot be deemed the "controller" of personal information from other websites. Confirming that a "right to be forgotten" does not exist in current legislation, Jääskinen drew attention to the existing 1995 EU Data Protection Directive and said: "The Directive does not establish a general 'right to be forgotten'."


AustrianTribune Specials

Giving the verdict in the e-book price-fixing case on Wednesday, US district judge Denise Cote said that Apple had conspired with five bigwig US book publishers to raise e-book prices. The lawsuit was filed against Apple by the US Department of...

Most Popular

Swiss company Roche has suffered a major setback as a...

A paper has been published in the journal Trends in...

A rare black jellyfish, also known as Black Nettle, has...

Dallas Democratic Rep. Eddie Bernice Johnson has...

Automotive News

  • Renault’s Dacia Unit in Romania Faces Strike

UK News

  • Woman Suffers ‘Foot Orgasm Syndrome’ after Gall Bladder Surgery
  • UK Astronomers to Make a Concerted Effort to Find Aliens
  • Scientist’s Survey Talks about Massive Under Ice Flood
  • Sir John Pendry Wins Top Institute of Physics Honor for the Idea of Invisibility Cloak
  • Plants Perform Arithmetic Calculations to Survive